675 shaares
35 results
tagged
ESR
"Companies like Scale AI first outsourced data work to wherever labor was cheapest. Now, they are recruiting physicians, lawyers, and Ph.D.s to generate and annotate data, rank model answers, and verify outputs. Higher credentials can raise the advertised rate, but the platform still controls payment and working conditions."
As Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly promoted and used in qualitative research, it also raises profound methodological issues. This position paper critically interrogates the role of generative AI (genAI) in the context of qualitative coding methodologies. Despite widespread hype and claims of efficiency, we propose that genAI is not methodologically valid within qualitative inquiries, and its use risks undermining the robustness and trustworthiness of qualitative research. The lack of meaningful documentation, commercial opacity, and the inherent tendencies of genAI systems to produce incorrect outputs all contribute to weakening methodological rigor. Overall, the balance between risk and benefits does not support the use of genAI in qualitative research, and our position paper cautions researchers to put sound methodology before technological novelty.
"LLMs are the perfect technology for manipulating the medical literature to say nearly anything you want via systematic review methods"
Section 2 du CoNRS
Notes sur l’usages des IA génératives
1 Engagements de la section
Attachés au principe d’évaluation de la recherche par les pairs, les membres de la section 2 du CoNRS ont voté à l’unanimité, lors de la session d’automne 2026, la motion suivante :
Les membres de la section s’engagent à ne jamais utiliser, dans le cadre de leur
mission au sein du CoNRS, des outils d’IA générative, ni en local ni en ligne.
Cela vaut notamment pour la synthèse de dossiers à évaluer ou la rédaction des
rapports.
Par conséquent, cette motion conservatoire implique aussi que les membres de la section s’engagent à ne jamais utiliser l’IA générative fournie par le CNRS (Emmy) lors de l’évaluation d’un dossier.
Notes sur l’usages des IA génératives
1 Engagements de la section
Attachés au principe d’évaluation de la recherche par les pairs, les membres de la section 2 du CoNRS ont voté à l’unanimité, lors de la session d’automne 2026, la motion suivante :
Les membres de la section s’engagent à ne jamais utiliser, dans le cadre de leur
mission au sein du CoNRS, des outils d’IA générative, ni en local ni en ligne.
Cela vaut notamment pour la synthèse de dossiers à évaluer ou la rédaction des
rapports.
Par conséquent, cette motion conservatoire implique aussi que les membres de la section s’engagent à ne jamais utiliser l’IA générative fournie par le CNRS (Emmy) lors de l’évaluation d’un dossier.
Dont la comparaison (qui ne tient pas) entre un LLM+agents et un compilateur.
ATECOPOL, 18 juin 2026
"What interests me most is the combination of universities’ self-image as incubators and world-leading labs of climate action and innovation, paired with the obscene energy bloat and fossil fuel hunger of generative AI. It’s something a little worse than mere hypocrisy, more in line with betrayal and treachery."
"The scientific literature can be viewed as an "information commons:" an intangible resource that "no one owns and is shared by everyone." There are well-established economic and political frameworks for understanding such commons, emerging from the history of agricultural common lands found in places like preindustrial England. This article provides a primer on the history and these frameworks, and considers a key difference between the information commons and the fields of yore: while information commons are robust and immensely valuable --- some can be said to rank among humanity's greatest achievements --- the English agricultural commons no longer meaningfully exist. The latter are gone not because of the well-known "tragedy of the commons," but rather a phenomenon known as the enclosure movement (~1600--1800) that transformed the common lands into private property. Many observers, then and now, judge enclosure to have been theft at a societal scale. This article argues that artificial intelligence (AI) provides precisely the tools needed to enable a previously-infeasible enclosure of the information commons. Although AI-enabled enclosure does not operate identically to physical enclosure, it shares the key features of turning the commons into private wealth and undermining the social systems that support them (via "slop spam"). The concepts presented in this article can provide a scholarly basis for interrogating the foreboding feeling that AI may represent not just a smash-and-grab, but an attack upon a whole way of life. "
FM: attention, à la fin de l'article Campus Matin se croit obligé de faire des résumés par des IAg !